Affiliate disclosure: Fit For Your Dog may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through certain links on this page, at no additional cost to you.
Disclosure: Fit For Your Dog may earn a commission from eligible purchases made through certain links, at no extra cost to you.
This guide is based on current brand information, nutrition pages, pricing details, and published policies rather than a paid hands-on feeding trial.
Read more about our process on How We Review.
Finding the best fresh dog food subscription is not as simple as choosing the brand with the nicest ingredient list. The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, and Nom Nom all deliver fresh or gently cooked food, but they differ in meal formats, pricing structure, storage requirements, retail availability, and how much flexibility they give you.
This research-based comparison looks at the factors that matter most before you subscribe: personalized portions, recipes, life-stage suitability, pricing, storage, feeding flexibility, and how easy each service is to try.
Quick picks
A personalized fresh-focused approach with Frozen Fresh and Instant Fresh formats.
See The Farmer’s Dog plans
Full Fresh, Half Fresh, Mixed Bowl, and Baked give owners more ways to manage budget and format.
See Ollie plans
Retail availability makes it easier to sample recipes before committing to a recurring plan.
See Nom Nom
The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie vs Nom Nom at a glance
Updated September 2026. Pricing, recipes, and offers can change. Personalized quotes may differ significantly by dog.
| Feature | The Farmer’s Dog | Ollie | Nom Nom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main format | Frozen Fresh + Instant Fresh | Full Fresh, Half Fresh, Mixed Bowl, Baked | Gently cooked fresh meals |
| Personalized portions | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Published starting price | About $2/day | Full Fresh from $1.57/meal; Half Fresh from $1.00/meal | Personalized quote |
| Partial-fresh option | Plan-dependent | Yes | Yes, half portions available |
| Retail trial option | Primarily direct | Sampler available | PetSmart, Chewy, Amazon availability |
| Best fit | Fresh-focused personalization | Maximum meal-format flexibility | Fresh food plus retail flexibility |
How we compared these fresh dog food subscriptions
We compared publicly available information from each brand, including meal formats, recipe choices, pricing information, personalized portioning, storage requirements, subscription flexibility, life-stage information, and options for trying the food before committing.
We have not completed a controlled side-by-side feeding trial with our own dogs. That means we do not assign star ratings based on appetite, stool quality, coat changes, energy, or long-term health observations that we have not personally measured.
For a deeper head-to-head look at two of these brands, see our The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie (2026) comparison.
1. The Farmer’s Dog
Good fit for: owners who want a personalized fresh-food-focused plan.
The Farmer’s Dog creates personalized meal plans using information about your dog such as age, weight, activity level, and food needs. Its prepared lineup includes Frozen Fresh and Instant Fresh, while a separate DIY Nutrient Mix option is available for owners who want to cook approved recipes at home.
Frozen Fresh is designed for cold storage, while Instant Fresh reduces freezer dependence and is intended for adult and senior dogs. Frozen Fresh options are available for puppies, adults, and seniors.
Pricing
The Farmer’s Dog says plans begin at about $2 per day. The actual quote varies by dog, recipe, calorie needs, and plan selection, so the advertised starting price should not be treated as an expected cost for every household.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Personalized portions
- Multiple fresh protein options
- Frozen Fresh covers multiple life stages
- Instant Fresh reduces freezer dependence
- Published starting price
Cons
- Exact pricing requires your dog’s details
- Frozen Fresh still needs refrigerator/freezer space
- Fewer prepared plan formats than Ollie
- Full fresh feeding can be costly for larger dogs
2. Ollie
Good fit for: owners who want maximum flexibility in how much fresh food they feed.
Ollie currently offers one of the most flexible plan structures in this comparison. Owners can choose among Full Fresh, Half Fresh, Mixed Bowl, and Baked plans, making it easier to balance fresh food, storage needs, and monthly budget.
Its current Fresh lineup includes beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, and pork options. Ollie states that its recipes are formulated to meet applicable AAFCO nutrient profiles.
Pricing
Ollie currently advertises Full Fresh from about $1.57 per meal and Half Fresh from about $1.00 per meal. Final pricing still depends on your dog and the plan selected.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Full Fresh and partial-fresh formats
- Five Fresh protein options
- Published starting-price examples
- Baked option reduces cold-storage dependence
- Fresh sampler available
Cons
- Full Fresh can still be expensive for large dogs
- More plan choices require closer comparison
- Fresh packs require refrigerator/freezer space
3. Nom Nom
Good fit for: owners who want fresh subscription food plus easier retail sampling.
Nom Nom offers gently cooked meals prepared around a dog’s caloric needs. Subscription customers can choose among recipes, full or half portions, and fixed or rotating recipe selections.
Nom Nom also stands out because owners can find products through retailers such as PetSmart, Chewy, and Amazon. That gives shoppers an easier way to let a dog sample the food before committing to a recurring online subscription.
Pricing
Nom Nom does not publish one universal daily subscription price. Cost varies with factors such as your dog’s age, current and ideal weight, activity level, location, recipe choice, and number of dogs.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Personalized subscription portions
- Full or half portion options
- Recipe rotation available
- Retail availability
- Easier to sample before subscribing
Cons
- Less transparent public subscription pricing
- Fresh meals require cold storage
- Personalized pricing makes direct cost comparison harder
Which fresh dog food subscription is cheapest?
There is no reliable universal winner because the three services personalize portions differently. The Farmer’s Dog advertises plans starting at about $2 per day. Ollie publishes plan-specific starting prices, including Full Fresh from about $1.57 per meal and Half Fresh from about $1.00 per meal. Nom Nom uses personalized quotes.
Compare the cost of supplying the same percentage of your dog’s daily calories. A half-fresh plan will naturally cost less than a full-fresh plan, so comparing unlike plans can be misleading.
Nutrition: what matters more than the marketing
Fresh-food brands often emphasize visible meat and vegetables, gentle cooking, or human-grade ingredients. Those characteristics can matter, but they do not replace the more important question: Is the exact recipe complete and balanced for your dog’s life stage?
AAFCO guidance emphasizes the nutritional adequacy statement because it identifies whether a food is complete and balanced and which life stage it is intended for. AAFCO itself does not “approve” individual dog foods.
Before subscribing, check the adequacy statement for the exact recipe and format you plan to feed, especially for puppies, large-breed growth, pregnant or nursing dogs, seniors, or dogs with unusual nutritional requirements.
What about dogs with medical conditions?
A fresh subscription is not automatically appropriate because a dog has allergies, digestive problems, kidney disease, pancreatitis, or another diagnosed condition. Subscription food is also not a substitute for a therapeutic or prescription diet when one has been recommended by a veterinarian.
- your dog has a diagnosed medical condition;
- your dog requires a prescription diet;
- your dog has a history of pancreatitis or gastrointestinal disease;
- your puppy has specific growth or large-breed nutritional requirements;
- you are making a major diet change after a veterinary recommendation.
How to choose between The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, and Nom Nom
The Farmer’s Dog may fit owners who prioritize a personalized fresh-food-focused program and like the choice between Frozen Fresh and Instant Fresh formats.
Ollie may fit owners who want the most flexibility in how much fresh food they feed and want options such as Full Fresh, Half Fresh, Mixed Bowl, or Baked.
Nom Nom may fit owners for whom retail availability and trying the food before starting a recurring subscription are especially important.
There is no single service that is automatically the right fit for every dog. Your dog’s life stage, calorie needs, storage space, budget, and health history all matter.
Frequently asked questions
Are fresh dog food subscriptions better than kibble?
Not automatically. Processing method is only one part of evaluating a diet. Nutritional adequacy, life stage, calories, your dog’s health, affordability, and whether you can feed the diet consistently are also important.
Which service offers the most meal-plan flexibility?
Ollie currently offers the widest clearly defined range of prepared meal formats in this comparison, including Full Fresh, Half Fresh, Mixed Bowl, and Baked. Nom Nom also offers flexibility through full or half portions and recipe rotation.
Can puppies eat these foods?
All three brands currently offer at least some options intended for puppies, but life-stage suitability depends on the exact recipe and format. Always check the nutritional adequacy statement before feeding a growing puppy.
Do I have to feed 100% fresh food?
No. Ollie offers partial-fresh formats, and Nom Nom can be configured with half portions. The best setup depends on your goals, budget, and the rest of your dog’s diet.
How quickly should I switch foods?
A gradual transition is usually easier on the digestive system. Brand transition guides commonly use roughly a one-week progression, but your veterinarian may recommend a different schedule for dogs with sensitive stomachs or medical conditions.
Final comparison
The Farmer’s Dog is a strong option for owners who want a personalized fresh-food-focused plan with Frozen Fresh and Instant Fresh formats.
Ollie stands out for feeding flexibility, especially if you want to control how much fresh food you feed without committing to a full-fresh plan.
Nom Nom stands out for combining subscription personalization with retail availability, making it easier to sample before committing.
The best fresh dog food subscription for your household is the one that fits your dog’s life stage, calorie needs, storage space, budget, and health needs while remaining practical enough to feed consistently.
Before deciding: request personalized pricing from each service and compare plans that provide the same percentage of your dog’s daily calories.
Explore related Fit For Your Dog guides
- The Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie (2026): Which Is Better for Your Dog?
- Dog Food & Nutrition Guides
- Dog Product Comparisons
- How We Review Dog Products
Sources & update notes
This guide was researched and updated for September 2026. Brand pricing, promotions, recipes, and policies can change.
Veterinary disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes and is not veterinary advice.
Consult your veterinarian before making major dietary changes, particularly if your dog is a puppy, pregnant, has allergies, gastrointestinal disease, kidney disease, pancreatitis, or requires a therapeutic diet.
